Top 5 Places To Go Toy Shopping in Brewster

The Brewster, New York, area has plenty of entertainment and leisure options available to its visitors and permanent residents. Whether you enjoy taking hikes down scenic trails, visiting historic mansions, or dining at some of the best restaurants in the state, the Hudson Valley is a melting pot of culture and entertainment that brings people back again and again.

While all of these activities may sound fun to adults, where do kids fit in? Luckily, our team at Brewster Ford has compiled a list of the top places to go toy shopping in and around Brewster that both kids and adults can enjoy. Whether you’re looking for a gift or a fun outing with your kids, you’re sure to like what these toy stores offer.

The Imperial Castle Toy Shop

The Imperial Castle Toy Shop, located in nearby Pawling, New York, has everything a child could ever want and more. With a massive selection of the hottest new toys, your kids are sure to find something to bring home. Popular items include Nerf guns, Funko Pops, Legos, LOL Dolls, and even slime kits for kids who like getting their hands dirty. In a hurry? Just use Imperial Castle’s online store.

Can’t find what you’re looking for? The staff at Imperial Castle are more than happy to custom order items upon request. Parents can enjoy their time at this shop thanks to their massive collection of vintage toys. Take a look at some relics from the past that will transport you right back to your childhood. Their vintage toys include Barbies, Transformers, Smurfs, Star Wars, and other items from iconic franchises. Unlike many other locally owned toy stores, Imperial Castle accepts several forms of payment, including cash, credit, debit, Venmo, PayPal, and Facebook Pay.

Location: 33 E. Main St., Pawling, New York

Phone: 845-493-0428

G. Willikers Toys and Games

Next on our list is G. Willikers Toys and Games, located just a short drive south from Brewster in Katonah, New York. This toy shop has three locations throughout New York, with the other two situated in Saratoga Springs and Albany. G. Willikers has a massive selection of toys, gifts, and games from the past and present that are sure to enthrall kids and parents alike.

Kids will love what this toy shop has to offer thanks to its wide selection of items geared toward children of all ages, ranging from infancy to school age. They can enjoy some of the store’s most popular items, such as stuffed animals, play dough, toy trucks, art kits, books, dress-up costumes, chalk, Frisbees, action figures, and much more.

Location: 29 Katonah Ave., Katonah, New York

Phone: 914-232-0706

The Toy Room

Just a quick 20-minute drive across the state line is The Toy Room, located in Bethel, Connecticut. Since 2006, this toy store has brought nostalgia and excitement to the community thanks to its wide selection of toys new and old, including board games, dolls, science kits, dress-up costumes, and books. Much like the other shops on this list, the vintage aesthetic of The Toy Room means it’s perfect for adults to roam as well. Take a look at some of the popular toys of the past decades, including Jack in the Box, Roller Wheels, and Ravensburger puzzles.

If you’re on the look for a vintage toy shop that offers competitive pricing and discounts, look no further. They also offer shipping to specific locations through their website or if you custom order an item in-store. If you’re in a hurry, you can order any of the store’s items on their website or call ahead and pick up your order in-store and even have them expertly gift-wrapped.

Location: 180 Greenwood Ave., Bethel, Connecticut

Phone: 203-791-0531

Play Toys and Gifts

Play Toys and Gifts is a toy store located nearby Brewster, across the state border in Connecticut. Play is unique because it’s specifically designed to be just as enjoyable for adults as it is for children. Here, you can find a wide assortment of retro toys, board games, and classic children’s books. They also have a wide selection of infant and toddler toys, making this store truly perfect for all ages.

Besides their more traditional toy selection, Play also has plenty of jewelry, artwork, candy, magic tricks, and other novelties. Find funny postcards, birthday cards, magnets, action figures, and other novelty products you likely won’t find anywhere else. A trip to Play is sure to satisfy everyone in your party, no matter their age or interests.

Location: 49 Bank St., New Milford, Connecticut

Phone: 860-355-2134

The Toy Chest

The final spot on our list is the Toy Chest, located just 20 minutes south across the state line in Ridgefield, Connecticut. This store has a wide variety of toys, games, puzzles, and arts and crafts kits that are sure to bring joy to children of all ages. They also have a wide selection of workbooks perfect for homeschooling or additional practice.

The Toy Chest offers personal shopping and curbside service, so if you’re not in the mood to browse in person, you can still buy everything you want. They also have a huge selection of toys from the past and today, including dolls, kites, Legos, Pokemon, Ravensburger puzzles, dress-up costumes, Russian nested dolls, putty, stuffed animals, and much more. They also offer complimentary gift wrapping, so if you’re looking for toys for a birthday or holiday gift, the Toy Chest has you covered.

Location: 441 Main St., Ridgefield, Connecticut

Phone: 203-431-9227

So, those are our top five picks for the best toy shops in and around Brewster, New York. We hope you found this list helpful and can use it the next time you’re in need of an entertaining outing for your little ones when you’re in the lower Hudson Valley. Did we accidentally leave out your favorite local toy store? If so, feel free to contact us at Brewster Ford, and we’ll be more than happy to add your suggestions to our list.

Tags: Local Stores
Posted in Local Tips | No Comments »