Best Pizza Places in Brewster, NY

The best pizza places are experts in balancing different flavors and mixing the perfect toppings on well-produced crust. Customer service also contributes to the ratings and determines whether a place can be among Brewster’s best pizza spots. Of course, you will appreciate exceptional service when placing your order at an establishment or waiting for delivery at home.

Whether you are living in the city, staycationing in Brewster, on a tailgating road trip, or just visiting for expert auto detailing services, a great pizza place enables you to enjoy the charm of this quaint village. The following are some of the best places to try.

Luigis Famiglia Cucina

Image via Unsplash by alanaktion

The name of the restaurant translates to the family kitchen in English. Luigi Rukaj and his sons own and operate the business, giving customers a nostalgic feeling of home away from home with their wide range of classic Italian pizzas. Many reviews from Tripadvisor can attest that the service makes you feel like part of the family, whether you are a resident or guest of New York.

The menu also consists of appetizers, desserts, pasta, soups, sandwiches, and salads. You can take your family for lunch or dinner and let the kids enjoy a customized pasta menu with butter, sauce, or meatballs. Luigis Famigla Cucina offer gluten-free options for people with allergies, although the kitchen is not gluten-free.

Aversano’s Pizzeria

Aversano has been serving the community for generations since two brothers, Paul and John Arvesano, launched the restaurant in 1986. The simple yet sophisticated atmosphere and Southern Italian recipes, including the famous New York-style pizza, Panini, calzones, and other take-out meals make this a great choice for a quick bite to eat. Their homemade tarter sauce complements the menu.

You can satisfy cravings or hunger with customized pizzas available by the slice or whole. If you want a drink with your meal, the bar offers a wide range of wines and cocktails. Furthermore, you can plan an event in Aversano’s private dining areas and the lounge, accommodating up to 100 guests.

You can customize your menu according to your guest’s specifications and theme, such as a graduation, office party, reunion, bridal shower, wedding, rehearsal dinner, etc. When enjoying your food, you can also access car oil change services in Brewster from experts who will have your vehicle ready by the end of your meal or event.

Portofino Pizza & Pasta

Located at 983 Route 22, Brewster, NY, the Portofino Pizza & Pasta serves hand-tossed pizzas, salads, and pasta that you can quickly order online. As a member of Slice, the restaurant uses the latest tech for order processing and meal preparation, thus ensuring quick delivery of top-notch food products. 

Portofino Pizza & Pasta creates every meal using fresh ingredients and adds your desired toppings. Their menu caters to everyone’s palates through a range of food products for all ages. If you are planning an event, the warm and friendly Portofino staff can attend to your requirements.

Gaetano Pizza

Gaetano is located at 100 Independent Way, only a few minutes drive from Brewster Hill, and is one of the best pizzerias in the Route 22 area. Even people from nearby towns like Pawling, New York, find the drive worthwhile because Gaetano always serves fresh, hot, and delicious meals. The restaurant starts making pizza when you order to avoid selling stale food that has overstayed on the shelves.

The restaurant also offers delicious calzones, chicken wings, desserts, wraps, and soups to cater to everyone’s needs. If you are on a diet, Gaetano Pizza offers vegetarian pizzas with fewer fats and calories, making them ideal for keeping your weight or blood pressure levels in check. There is also a gluten-free pizza.

The casual dining atmosphere caters to the entire family, including kids. If you are taking the kids and loved one’s car hunting for a new or certified pre-owned vehicle, you can stop by and enjoy such an outing.

5 Brothers Pizza & Pasta

Located at 2505 Carmel Ave., this establishment has an extensive menu and can easily pass for a full-service restaurant. When you are on a road trip from the East to the West on Interstate 84, you can leave the highway at Exit 19 to curb hunger pangs and quench your thirst with soft drinks or a local root beer. The environment at 5 Brothers Pizza & Pasta is practical and clean.

Off-peak is during late lunch and early dinner, so it would be ideal to pass by at these times if you are with family or friends and want to have the place to yourselves. Their menu is characterized by generous portion sizes of pizzas, salads, and lasagnas. Their free delivery service allows you to order from home or the office at no extra cost.

Pizza Place & Trattoria

The Pizza Place & Trattoria’s convenient location at 35 Main Street makes the restaurant ideal for out-of-town orders and those passing through Brewster, New York. The restaurant has plenty of metered parking spaces. It ranks among the top restaurants in the area because of its experience in cooking Brooklyn-style pizza.

Although a bit pricey compared to most other establishments on this list, Pizza Place & Trattoria gives you value for money with their well-cooked crust and homemade sauces. Also, the staff are friendly and the environment is clean.

Pizza is a popular dish in New York, and you can order a customized one from any of these restaurants.  You can request a variety of toppings, such as vegetables, meats, or even fruits. Did we miss your favorite pizza place? Contact us to let us know they should be on the list. 

If you have a big family and need a car that can fit everyone when going out for pizza, buy or lease an SUV of your choice from a local dealership. Even when you are on the road and want to eat on the move, such a spacious car allows you to savor the different flavors of Brewster, New York.
The post Best Pizza Places in Brewster, NY appeared first on Brewster Ford Blog.
Source: blog

Posted in Uncategorized | No Comments »