Best Pizza Places Around Brewster, NY

Brewster, NY, might be a small town, but when it comes to pizza, it offers big flavors and plenty of choices. Whether you’re a fan of classic New York-style slices or prefer something more gourmet, Brewster has some fantastic pizza spots. From family-owned pizzerias with decades of tradition to newer places putting a modern twist on old favorites, there’s something for every pizza lover here. Let’s look at some of the best pizza places within a 30-minute drive of Brewster, NY, and see what makes each one special.

Pizza Place & Trattoria

First up is Pizza Place & Trattoria, located in the heart of Brewster. This local gem has been serving up delicious pizza for years and is known for its warm, welcoming atmosphere. Pizza Place & Trattoria specializes in classic, New York-style pizza with a thin, crispy crust and just the right amount of sauce and cheese. Their Margherita pizza, topped with fresh basil and mozzarella, offers a simple yet incredibly flavorful experience. Pizza Place & Trattoria is perfect for a casual night out with friends or a quick slice on the go, and their friendly service keeps locals coming back for more.

Pizza & Pasta 22

If you’re looking for a spot that offers more than just pizza, Pizza & Pasta 22 in Brewster is a great choice. As the name suggests, this restaurant serves up a variety of Italian dishes, but their pizza is what truly shines. With a menu that includes both traditional and specialty pies, there’s something for everyone. Their Chicken Cutlet Ala Vodka Square Pizza, topped with creamy vodka sauce and mozzarella, is a crowd favorite, offering a rich and indulgent take on the classic slice. The cozy, family-friendly environment makes Pizza & Pasta 22 a great spot for dinner with loved ones.

La Familia Pizzeria

La Familia Pizzeria, located in Brewster, NY, is a family-owned establishment that has delighted pizza lovers for years. What sets La Familia apart is its commitment to quality ingredients and time-honored recipes. Their Grandma Pizza is a must-try with its thin crust, fresh tomato sauce, and generous garlic and basil topping. The pizzeria has a warm, inviting atmosphere that makes you feel right at home, whether dining in or grabbing a pie. La Famiglia is a place where tradition meets flavor, making it a top choice for pizza in the area.

Gaetano’s Pizza & Café

Located in Brewster, NY, Gaetano’s Pizza & Café offers a gourmet twist on classic pizza. This stylish spot is known for its creative menu, which includes a variety of artisanal pizzas made with fresh, high-quality ingredients. The Marsala Pizza, topped with mushrooms, chicken, and Marsala sauce, is a perfect example of their innovative approach. The modern yet cozy atmosphere makes it a great spot for a date night or a special meal with friends.

Pizza in Brewster, NY

Brewster, NY, is home to some of the best pizza places you’ll find in the region. From the classic New York-style slices at Pizza Place and Trattoria to the gourmet creations at Gaetano’s Pizza & Café, there’s no shortage of options for pizza lovers. Each of these spots offers something unique, whether it’s a time-honored family recipe or a creative twist on a traditional pie. So next time you’re craving a delicious slice, head out to one of these top pizza joints and enjoy a meal that’s sure to satisfy. And when planning your pizza outings, remember that Brewster Ford is here to ensure you get there in comfort and style. Happy eating!

Image credit: Heavenly Slice by Ivan Torres licensed by Unsplash License

Tags: Local Restaurants
Posted in Local Restaurants | No Comments »